DEPARTMENT OF LAW PROVIDES
UPDATE ON GASOLINE PRICING INVESTIGATION
November 24, 2008
At the direction of Governor Sarah Palin, the Department of Law
began an investigation into the pricing of gasoline in Alaska.
The investigation was initiated in August, following the decline
of gasoline prices across the country as the price of crude oil
began to drop from record highs near $150 a barrel in July. Gasoline
prices in Alaska, however, did not follow national trends, and
soon became the highest in the nation. The Department's investigation
is focused on explaining the slow decline of gasoline prices
in Alaska, and whether the price of gasoline is the result of
any illegal conduct, like price fixing or other collusive behavior.
The Department's investigation is ongoing, and must remain confidential
under state law. According to a news release, the Department
has gathered significant information from refiners, distributors,
and retailers about the pricing of gasoline, and continues to
gather additional data and information. The Department has retained
Barry Pulliam, a Senior Economist at the Los Angles firm of Econ
One, to assist the Department in its investigation. The Department
has also attended two House Judiciary Committee hearings convened
to discuss gasoline pricing issues.
The following is some useful information provided by Alaska's
Department of Law about gasoline pricing generally that may help
explain some of the pricing for gasoline in Alaska.
1. The State of Alaska (or
any state) does not regulate gasoline prices. Refiners, distributors,
and retailers can sell gasoline at any price they want so long
as those prices are not the result of collusive behavior, like
"price fixing." If the price reached an "unconscionable"
level, the price could also violate Alaska's consumer protection
2. Because gasoline pricing is not regulated, economic forces
including the available supply, consumer demand, and competition
in the marketplace are the primary factors that determine gasoline
3. Alaska does not have a price gouging law. Sellers of all goods
and services (including gasoline) are not required to sell products
on a "cost plus" basis. Thus, it does not matter what
it costs the seller to acquire the goods or provide a service.
Sellers can sell their products for whatever the market will
bear. There is no "cap" on the amount of profit any
business can make.
4. It does not matter what gasoline prices were when the price
of oil was the same as it is today. For example, if refiners
sold gasoline for $1.10/gallon when oil was $60 a barrel, this
does not require them to sell it for $1.10 every time oil is
$60 a barrel.
5. The price of gasoline in the lower 48 is not a good indicator
of what prices "should be" in Alaska. The competitive
forces that operate to control gasoline prices in the lower 48
are completely different from Alaska. The dynamics of supply,
demand, and competition are unique in Alaska.
6. The demand for gasoline is not as "price sensitive"
in Alaska as it is in other parts of the country. This means
that regardless of the price, the demand does not change by much.
This creates less incentive for suppliers to lower their price
compared to areas of the country where demand drops significantly
when prices rise.
7. Gasoline sold in Southeast Alaska is barged up from the Pacific
Northwest and from Cook Inlet. Because fuel is only barged in
once a month or every few months, it takes longer for prices
to reflect current market conditions. It may take two or three
months to exhaust current supply before less (or more) expensive
gasoline is available and sold to retailers.
8. Some cities and boroughs charge tax on fuel sales. In the
Kenai and Soldotna area, for example, the pump price adds a 6%
city and borough tax that is not present in other cities, like
Anchorage. Coupled with lower volumes and fewer stations, prices
will tend to be higher in these communities.
The Department of Law plans to complete its investigation to
determine if there is any illegal activity among gasoline sellers
that may be a cause of the high price of gasoline, and will prepare
a summary of its findings when the investigation is done.
Source of News:
E-mail your news &
photos to firstname.lastname@example.org
Alaska Department of Law
Publish A Letter in SitNews Read Letters/Opinions
Contact the Editor
Stories In The News