October 20, 2014
Monday PM

According to Southeast Conference, Southeast Alaska’s economy is increasingly stable, diverse, and strong. Bolstered by the powerful twin engines of fishing and tourism – drawing $1 billion each to the region annually – the Tongass is not unlike the proverbial goose that is laying golden eggs.

With a board, staff, and thousands of supporters all living and working between Ketchikan and Yakutat, SEACC is fully invested in the economic future of Southeast Alaska. We too are raising families here and want our kids to be able to live and work here. We too value livelihoods based on natural resources. Not only am I the Executive Director of SEACC, I also fish with my partner, a commercial power troller who’s fished out of Petersburg for the last 13 years. As one of Alaska’s fishing families, we recognize that our industry requires clean water and healthy fisheries to stay viable. I do my job at SEACC to ensure the future of our family business, and the ability of our children to make a living off the land and sea.

SEACC has consistently supported a dozen locally-owned small sawmills with brochures, videos, and advertising. We’ve also collaborated on innovative community forestry projects that keep timber dollars in the region. Recognizing that our communities need diverse and sustainable income streams, we’ve supported Ketchikan's Alaska Ship and Drydock, and have hired staff tasked with growing Wrangell’s marine services capacity and supporting its expanded shipyard and new marine travel lift.

We support Southeast Alaska’s $1 billion commercial fishing industry, now the most lucrative and productive salmon fishery in all of Alaska, which according to Senator Lisa Murkowski, provides more local household incomes than timber, mining, oil, and gas combined. We also support tourism, the region’s second largest economic driver, using our materials to promote local charter and recreational businesses.

Like most Alaskans, we want our children and grandchildren to enjoy the same unique way of life and bright economic prospects we do. To ensure this, we believe economic development today should not come at the expense of economic development tomorrow. Similarly, one industry should not “pollute the waters” of another industry. And if we are to keep our communities strong and vibrant, profits from industry should stay in the region, with local people working together to chart the path of development in their communities.

While we work hard to support development that meet these common-sense criteria, projects still get proposed that have limited economic benefits to the region, threaten future economic prosperity, or undercut other vital economic activity. With roughly 6,000 acres of proposed clearcuts, up to half of which could be exported overseas without any local processing, the Big Thorne timber sale is one of these projects.

We agree with the growing number of Southeast Alaskans who believe that one-off, old-growth clearcuts should remain a thing of the past. Indeed, there is widespread, popular support for moving forward with a forest plan that builds on our region’s economic success by helping, not harming, our real economic drivers: fishing and tourism.
Southeast Conference reports that timber brought in just $17 million to the region in 2013, less than 1% of fishing and tourism’s combined $2 billion, and below even our region’s arts sector in economic value. Meanwhile, American taxpayers are subsidizing the export-oriented Tongass timber program at $20 million per year – or $130,000 per Tongass timber job, as the New York Times recently reported. While our taxpayers swallow a net economic loss, our old-growth forests are shipped back to us from Asia as profitable products.

If the goal is prosperous communities on the Tongass, the Tongass National Forest’s budget would be better invested sustaining fisheries, expanding recreation opportunities for locals and paying visitors, and setting up small mill owners and restoration crews to transition to primarily young-growth timber for local markets. Sure, selective old-growth logging will always have a place on the Tongass, but let’s make sure we maximize jobs per log cut at small mills around the region, rather than export our remaining old-growth – and jobs – at an unsustainable rate.

Community forestry has a vital, if supplemental, economic role to play in Southeast Alaska. The good news is that a local wood industry is compatible not only with fishing and tourism, but also with forest management for wildlife and hunting. If the Forest Service, the state of Alaska, and local people work together, we can remove the remaining economic barriers – ending round log exports, for one – to a sustainable forest products industry in which local families have stable employment processing local wood for local markets.

But we won’t get there if the Forest Service’s “Tongass transition” continues to pour public money into divisive old-growth clearcuts that export local jobs.

Southeast Alaska’s natural resources can provide unparalleled economic opportunities for local people for generations to come, if we spend our dollars wisely and make smart management decisions now. Instead of cooking the goose that lays our golden eggs, let’s lay the foundation for future economic prosperity today.

Malena Marvin
Executive Director of
Southeast Alaska Conservation Council
Juneau, Alaska

Received October --, 2014 - Published October 20, 2014

Viewpoints - Opinion Letters:

Webmail Your Opinion Letter to the Editor

 

SitNews ©2014
Stories In The News
Ketchikan, Alaska

Articles & photographs that appear in SitNews may be protected by copyright and may not be reprinted without written permission from and payment of any required fees to the proper sources. E-mail your news & photos to editor@sitnews.us Photographers choosing to submit photographs for publication to SitNews are in doing so granting their permission for publication and for archiving. SitNews does not sell photographs. All requests for purchasing a photograph will be emailed to the photographer.