SitNews - Stories in the News - Ketchikan, Alaska


Gravina Road project
By Malcom Menzies


July 04, 2007

I appreciate Don Hoff's passionate opposition to the Gravina Road project (June 28; As Ketchikan turns, so do our lives) and respect his right to voice his opinion, but feel it necessary to clarify several points he made.

The Gravina Island Road is not being developed solely for the benefit of a handful of landowners. To the contrary, it will be a public road which will provide access to more than 1,000 acres of sorely needed developable land on the island. It is a component of the Gravina Access Project and part of the Ketchikan Gateway Borough master plan, which was developed by the community leaders after much public input and open deliberation.

The project has no direct benefit to any timber activities and would not provide access to the remote land on the island that is owned by the previous governor.

As to the cost of the project, it is indeed expensive. Unfortunately, it is not out of line with the high cost of road construction in Alaska and in fact is cheaper per mile than the current Tongass Highway projects.

Because Gravina road is a design-build project, the $25.7 million cost includes design and environmental costs that would not normally be shown in more traditional design/bid/build road projects.

If you remove the engineering design and environmental permitting costs ($3.5 million) and the two bridges ($5.5 million) from Gravina Road, you can compare the construction costs with other Ketchikan projects now underway. By doing that you find that it costs $4.9 million per mile to construct the 3.4 mile road. By contrast, South Tongass Highway, which is currently under construction, costs $5.1 million per mile. The North Tongass Highway project costs $6.1 million per mile. Both of these projects are paved reconstructions and less than two miles in length, but the type of work is similar enough to compare. While Gravina Road is cheaper than the two projects mentioned above, no doubt all are expensive. It is a fact of Alaskan life that road construction up here is an expensive proposition. I share Mr Hoff's wish that it wasn't the case.

Malcom Menzies
DOT&PF Southeast Region Director
Juneau, AK

Received July 03, 2007 - Published July 04, 2007

About: Malcom Menzies is the Alaska Departmnet of Transportation & Public Facilities Southeast Region Director.

Related Viewpoint:

letter As Ketchikan turns, so do our lives - Don Hoff - Hixson, TN

Viewpoints - Opinion Letters:

letter Webmail Your Opinion Letter to the Editor


Note: Comments published on Viewpoints are the opinions of the writer
and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Sitnews.


E-mail your letters & opinions to
Your full name, city and state are required for publication.

SitNews ©2007
Stories In The News
Ketchikan, Alaska