SitNews - Stories in the News - Ketchikan, Alaska


Oceans Alaska
Submitted By Kirk Thomas for Various Ketchikan Businesses


April 28, 2010
Wednesday PM

Dear Sitnews Editor,

We, the undersigned, are writing you this letter to state our strong opposition to Oceans Alaska (formerly known as the Tongass Aquarium) becoming a shore excursion tour operator for cruise passengers here in Ketchikan, Alaska. Oceans Alaska has promoted and represented itself as a research, education and shellfish mariculture facility and has successfully applied for and been granted public seed money for all of the progress they have made thus far.

In 2008, the initial response to their $750,000 request for funding for the" Rainforest Interpretive Trail" from the Ketchikan Gateway Borough Planning Liaison and Economic Development Advisory Committee (PLEDAC) was that "a conflict exists between public and private enterprises and would interfere in the competitive process by providing an advantage to the applicant." After this they proposed a more toned down request for the $500,000 "Marine Science Center for Alaska." When funding was not forthcoming, in March 2010, that same committee recommended on their Community Economic Development Priority (CEDS) list the inclusion of an Oceans Alaska request for 11 million dollars. Oceans Alaska has made great strides on its own behalf by promising jobs and a world class research facility while skirting the issue that their use of public funds would be in direct competition with private enterprise.

Oceans Alaska has publicly announced that operating expenses for the Marine Science Center will be provided by revenue from an estimated 150,000 tourists annually. Further, Oceans Alaska intends to make their excursion a destination to include a gift shop and seafood restaurant. With the decline in cruise visitors to Ketchikan that would mean that a non-profit (non tax paying entity) would be drawing a significant percentage of potential business from the already struggling privately owned tour operators (tax- paying companies).

Our businesses are self funded. We pay for our own marketing, staff and development. We employ hundreds of people and funnel millions of dollars into the local economy. Should we be expected to compete with a proposed large aquarium complex funded with public tax dollars? If we Alaskans approve of this publicly subsidized shore excursion business, essentially we will be consenting to the end of many of our small established businesses located all over Ketchikan, many of whom operate on the smallest margin of profit.

In 2009 Ketchikan tour operators and retail stores saw a drop in revenue of 10-40% due to fewer passengers and cruise ship stops. That percentage is expected to rise in 2010. This will further impact our small community.

Oceans Alaska speculates that they will "positively impact" the economy of Ketchikan. With the shortest port times in Alaska, Ketchikan businesses already struggle to serve guests who are only in port for 5 to 6 hours. Taking those guests to the remote Herring Cove area for a 3+ hour tour will mean that those guests won't have any other opportunity to visit privately owned shore excursions or retail stores, or other publicly funded facilities such as Totem Bight, The Tongass Museum and the USFS Discovery Center. How can these subsidized shore excursions possibly have a "positive impact" on our local economy?

We could support Oceans Alaska's original mission as a research and education facility which will help the fledgling mariculture industry but not as a tourist attraction. We call on you to include language in your funding that as a publicly funded entity, Oceans Alaska may not compete with private enterprise, including, but not limited to, shore excursion tours sold aboard the cruise ships.

Respectfully Submitted,
by Kirk Thomas for:

AAA Moving & Storage
Action Jackson Charters
Air Marine Harbor
Alaska Amphibious Tours
Alaska Aquamarine Experience Inc.
Alaska Commercial Divers
Alaska Diesel Power Inc.
Alaska Fisheries
Alaska Hummer Adventures
Alaskan Trading Co.
Alaska Pest Management Inc.
All Dimensions Construction
Almost Home Vacation Rentals
Annabelle's Famous Keg and Chowder House
Asian Garden Restaurant
Basic Transportation Co. Inc.
Big Fish Charters
Capistrano Properties, LLC
Carriage Works
Commercial Fishing Ventures
Computer HQ
(Bering Sea Crab Fisherman's Tour)
Carlin Air
Cedars Lodge
Clover Bay Lodge
Clover Pass Lodge
Crazy Wolf Studio
Dockside Galley
Dolly's Enterprises
Dolly's House Museum
Duckworth & Duckworth
Experience Alaska Tours
First City Car Rentals
Forget Me Knot Charters
Gateway Seafoods and Smokehouse
George Inlet Lodge
Gilmore Hotel
Gold Rush
Harbor Barber
Hasty Construction
Island Wings Air Service
Joe Schwierking Inspection
Ketchikan Adventure Tours
Ketchikan H2O
Ketchikan Kitchen & Bath
Ketchikan Reservation Service
Knudson Cove Marina
Lighthouse Excursion Inc.
Lighthouse Marine
Loggerville Holdings LLC
Miles D. Enright Company, Inc.
My Office
Narrows Inn
Northend Construction
North Shore Gardens
Northern Tours, LLC
Northern Lights Greenhouse & Garden Supply
Outback Doghouse Cafe
PC Hydraulics
Premier Auto Body
Purified Water To Go
Rainforest Web Design
RDM Air Service
Rorys Marine
Salmon, Etc.
Salmon Falls Lodge
Sea Imports
Silver King Lodge
Silver Thimble
Snorkel Alaska
Snow's Cove Lodge and Tours
Sockeye Sams
Sound Adventures
Sourdough Tours
Southeast Exposure
Steve's Gas & Diesel Repair
Strike Zone Sportfishing
Super 8 Motel
Tall Tale Taxidermy
The Auto Works
The Dog House
The Great Alaskan Lumberjack Show
The Forget-Me-Not Sweater Shoppe
The Point
The Mecca
Timber & Marine Supply Inc.
Tongass Trading Company, Inc.
TSS. Inc.
Vogul Jewelery
Voss Company
Ward Cove Construction
Ward Creek Industrial
Ward Creek Mini Storage
White Marine Repair


Received April 28, 2010 - Published April 28, 2010


On the Web:

Oceans Alaska


Viewpoints - Opinion Letters:

letter Webmail Your Opinion Letter to the Editor



Note: Comments published on Viewpoints are the opinions of the writer
and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Sitnews.


E-mail your letters & opinions to
Your full name, city and state are required for letter publication.

SitNews ©2010
Stories In The News
Ketchikan, Alaska