Sitnews - Stories In The News - Ketchikan, Alaska - Opinions



RE: Another option for new library structure
by Karen Hollywood


March 10, 2004

About the Library: I admit I am one of those people that seldom speaks out, believing the city will do what it wants, (as I have seen them do for the past 25 years) regardless of what Ketchikan's citizens do or don't agree with.

I would like to add to the letter from Patrick Jirschele. I do not know him, or how long he has lived here, but want to congratulate him on such an elequent letter in reference to the proposed design for the upcoming library building replacement/ expansion, etc.

I showed my children the front page picture of the paper and told them before I'd read it, "You can tell the guy that designed this doesn't live here." We went on to read it and of course I was right. No one in their right mind would put that much glass in such a windy place-- one flying stick or drive by BB gun (how could some kids resist?) and we have expensive repairs (or must pay for bulletproof glass to begin with?). I noted that there was much glorious light coming into -- oh! nothing! Not the inside of the building, not the library itself, just on the giant display plane. Even though planes are a large part of Ketchikan's history and 'lore', fishing boats are and have always been even more so. Proportions should be switched. So the details of the design are flawed (not sure why, but the inaccuracy offends me), and geting rid of the "warm interior" offends me more. I did not look at the one in Juneau. The "architect's rendition" on the front page of our weekend paper was enough. SOMEONE, PLEASE INVESTIGATE Mr. Jirschele's "Creek" ideas (EXCELLENT, btw), before the city pours way too much of our money into ANOTHER thing we can all do nothing but grumble about.

We supposedly take pride in our old fashioned 'small town' Alaskan First City looks. We left the big glass buildings in the big cities we all came from. I prefer some glass (YES-LIGHT!), but soft warmth over modern (out of place in the neighborhood) facades.

Karen Hollywood
Ketchikan, AK - USA


Related Viewpoint:

Another option for new library structure not yet explored by Patrick Jirschele - Ketchikan, AK - USA


Museum Expansion Plan Unveiled...
Thursday - March 04, 2004


Note: Comments published on Viewpoints are the opinions of the writer
and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Sitnews.



Post a Comment -------View Comments

Submit an Opinion - Letter

Stories In The News
Ketchikan, Alaska