SitNews - Stories in the News - Ketchikan, Alaska

Viewpoints: Letters / Opinions

Newt's Court Proposals Dangerous
By George Kiser


February 08, 2012
Wednesday AM


Newt Gingrich apparently thinks the Founding Fathers made a terrible mistake when they established an independent court system.  Under his proposals, judges would please the President, Congress, and the public -- or suffer the consequences.  Presidents could ignore court decisions they dislike. Congress could haul judges before it to explain their decisions and jail non-compliant judges, and unpopular judges could be fired and their courts abolished.

Even some very conservative judicial critics have expressed outrage at Gingrich's proposals. One of George W. Bush's Attorneys General (Michael Mukasey) called them "outrageous and dangerous;"  Another (Alberto Gonzalez) condemned "bringing judges
before Congress, like a schoolchild being brought before the principal."  Columnist George Will wrote that Gingrich would replace legal reasoning with "raw political power."

The Gingrich plan is not totally untested.  Joseph Goebbels, Hitler's Propaganda Minister, argued that German judges tended to rely too much on legal reasoning, too little on public opinion and Hitler's wishes.  For this offense, judges should be fired and their courts abolished.  Like Gingrich, Goebbels said these "reforms" would protect "the people" against oppressive courts.  They became law, the last remnants of freedom vanished, and we learned an invaluable lesson.  Or did we? (Louis P. Lochner, ed., Goebbels Diaries, Doubleday:  pgs. 127, 138,173-4, 192, 447).

George Kiser
Bloomington, IL

About: " I recently retired from Illinois State University, where I taught courses on the courts for 35 years."

Received February 07, 2012 - Published February 08, 2012



Viewpoints - Opinion Letters:

letter Webmail Your Opinion Letter to the Editor



Representations of fact and opinions are solely those of the author.
The opinions of the author do not represent the opinions of Sitnews.


E-mail your letters & opinions to
Your full name, city and state are required for letter publication.

SitNews ©2012
Stories In The News
Ketchikan, Alaska