SitNews - Stories in the News - Ketchikan, Alaska


Re: Dungeness Crab
By Lloyd Gossman


February 17, 2011

In short response to Max Worhatch,  nobody cares that you're appalled by my lack of knowledge on Dungeness Crab. However, you can look at the internet as well as anybody else and find out the Southeast Alaska Dungeness Crab fishery is not the most conservatively managed Dungeness fishery in the world.  You're wrong on that account.

Also, maybe you forgot, we (crab fisherman,  processors, and others  around Ketchikan) stopped the summer commercial Dungeness crab  fishery in districts one and two many years ago and went to a winter fishery because of the terrible waste.  That was recently changed by the commercially driven Board of Fish.

If the Sea Otter, overfishing, or anything else, was jeopardizing the Dungeness Crab fishery, how could anybody be so stupid as to change from a sustainable winter fishery to a summer fishery wasting more of the crab when they are becoming more valuable or scarce? Let me repeat myself – we had a winter commercial Dungeness crab fishery – no one was keeping the commercial folks from fishing them. It was just plain stupid to change and start fishing the crab in the summer when you waste them and jeopardize the resource.

It’s normal for the commercial interests to think they alone have the right to unlimited fish, crab, whatever, and huge amounts of wasteful bycatch at everyone’s expense, because that’s how they make a living. You can’t argue or reason with someone who puts food on the table or supports his family by commercial fishing. Commercial fisherman have the ultimate entitlement and are supported by  the Board of Fish who has been given ultimate authority by Alaska Statutes.

I live in a world with limits on what I can catch. My limits are determined by unrestricted commercial catch results and their wasteful bycatch. If the stocks are fished out then subsistence users, personal use, and sports  fisherman just have to accept it. But we sure as heck don’t have to like it or keep quiet about it.

I’m getting tired of the same old line of how much the commercial fishing industry  puts into Alaska. From another perspective – Subsistence users, personal use, and sport fisherman put more into the Alaska economy-have less affect on the resource, and don’t need a Board of Fish loaded with commercial fisherman and bought off by the commercial fishing industry from Puget sound.

Lloyd Gossman
Ketchikan, AK


Received February 15, 2011 - Published February 17, 2011


Related Viewpoint:

letter Dungeness Crab By Max Worhatch IV

Viewpoints - Opinion Letters:

letter Webmail Your Opinion Letter to the Editor



Note: Comments published on Viewpoints are the opinions of the writer
and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Sitnews.


E-mail your letters & opinions to
Your full name, city and state are required for letter publication.

SitNews ©2011
Stories In The News
Ketchikan, Alaska