SitNews - Stories in the News - Ketchikan, Alaska

Viewpoints: Letters / Opinions

State Commission’s Rejection of S. 730 Merits Praise
By Myla Poelstra


November 10, 2011

On October 28, 2011, the State of Alaska Citizen’s Advisory Commission on Federal Areas held a public meeting where testimony was taken on S. 730 and HR. 1408, the Sealaska Land Bills, now before Congress.  

The Commissioners, appointed by the Governor and State Legislature, voted unanimously to nix this legislation.  
CACFA rejected these bills after two years of fact finding that included discussions with Congressional staff, meetings with Sealaska, and review of public testimony and letters.

After a thorough evaluation, CACFA reached the same conclusion that USDA Undersecretary Harris Sherman made during the Senate hearing on S.730: “The selections identified by Sealaska within the original withdrawal areas are more than sufficient to meet Sealaska’s remaining ANCSA entitlement.”

The Commission’s comments further echoed Sherman’s view that, “neither S.730 nor HR.1408 will accomplish [completion of the entitlement] in a manner that is fair and equitable to all of the residents and communities who depend on the resources of the Tongass National Forest.”

The heart of the issue is that Sealaska needs to finalize the selections it requested from the BLM in 2008, which are in the area they asked Congress for in 1976 through the testimony of John Borbridge, Sealaska’s President.

Thirty five years is too long for Sealaska to come back and upset the apple cart by going hundreds of miles from the 1976 areas.  The USFS Tongass Land Management Plan and Transition planning would be thrown out the window by this bill.

In order for Sealaska to receive their current legislative selections, families and businesses that have lived and worked in the region for decades would, in fact, be thrown to the wolves.  

Rather than “jobs protection”, the consequences of this legislation are the destruction of jobs and the ruin of communities.

I am grateful to CACFA for voicing the same valid concerns the Nine Towns most affected by the bills have raised: NO NEW LEGISLATION IS NECESSARY to settle Sealaska’s land claims.  

Passed in 1971, ANCSA was and is a fair, just, and equitable settlement of all claims.  CACFA has taken a position based on true facts and their conclusions are valid.

Hopefully, Governor Parnell and our Congressional Delegation will respect CACFA’s letter by encouraging Sealaska Corp. to move forward and get their just entitlement by dropping this unfair legislation.

Myla Poelstra
Kosciusko Island
Edna Bay, AK

Received November 07, 2011 - Published November 10, 2011


Passage of Lands Bill Not Supported by Governor's Citizen’s Advisory Commission on Federal Areas - In a letter to U.S. Senator Lisa Murkowski, Rep. Wes Keller, Chairman of Alaska's Citizens' Advisory Commission of Federal Areas said the Commission has concluded that Sealaska Corporation's land entitlement under Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (ANCSA) can be met with the currently selected lands in the existing withdrawals and that neither S. 730 nor H.R. 1408 will accomplish this in a manner that is fair and equitable to all the residents and communities who depend on the resources in the Tongass National Forest. In the letter, Keller included detailed reasons why the Citizens' Advisory Commission of Federal Areas cannot support passage of S. 730 or H.R. 1408. - More...
SitNews - Nov. 10, 2011


Viewpoints - Opinion Letters:

letter Webmail Your Opinion Letter to the Editor



Note: Comments published on Viewpoints are the opinions of the writer
and do not represent the opinions of Sitnews.


E-mail your letters & opinions to
Your full name, city and state are required for letter publication.

SitNews ©2011
Stories In The News
Ketchikan, Alaska